Showing posts with label Genre. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Genre. Show all posts

Monday, March 9, 2009

What Is UF? (The Elevator Pitch Version)

NOTE: This is NOT the blog post I've been planning for days now but I couldn't resist...

Writers of Urban Fantasy often come across the same dilemma.

It goes like this:

Conversation with average-off-the-street-and-fairly-well-educated-types eventually comes around to vocation. You say you're a novelist and then...

They say:
Oh you're a writer!
We:
*nod* (& add a reassuring smile)
Then they say:
What sort of stuff do you write?
We say:
Urban Fantasy
They say:
What's that, exactly?
We:
*take a deep breath then ramble, trying definition #32 for the day in an attempt to encompass both the genre we love and write in AND our new novel which would seem to not quite fit within the confines of said definition*
They say:
"Oh." *and either look confused and wonder if you know what you're doing or decide you're writing another version of Twilight or Buffy*
We:
*sigh and decide we'll try definition #33 next time we're asked this question*

The writers over at The League of Reluctant Adults, have been thinking about this recently as well and comments were invited to suggest the ultimate 'one-liner' for a definition of what Urban Fantasy really is. Here are some of my favorite responses:

Blogger Jaye Wells said...

Fantastical tales set in modern times that blend elements from the mystery, horror, romance, and traditional fantasy genres.

Blogger Heather said...

"It's real life for people like me who believe in fairies." Or "It's like if Narnia came out of the wardrobe instead of the other way around."

Anonymous Thom said...

It's stories about the paranormal in the modern world, kind of like horror in as far as there are kewl supernatural folks, but with far less gore and far more sex.

Blogger December/Stacia said...

Usually something about magic and/or magical/paranormal creatures in modern or urban or suburban society.

Blogger -Kelly Meding said...

"Harry Potter with sex!"

"It's like Twilight, only with vampires."

OpenID silveradept said...

"What if there really were vampires, fairies and werewolves, and they're your next-door neighbors?"

Bloggertalshannon said...

Urban Fantasy: Modern, everyday life with a fantasy twist. So if your next door neighbors were elves, that would be Urban Fantasy. If your cat turned into a sexy cat-man one day while you were vacuuming, that would be Urban Fantasy. If you found out you had invisible fairy wings, that would be a miracle (and it would also be Urban Fantasy).

Please note: the above quotes are excerpted from people's comments. Most had a lot more to say than a single sentence! For the whole post and all comments please click HERE.

So what's my elevator-pitch definition of UF?

Well I shy away from saying 'paranormal' or 'supernatural' because to me that not only means ghosts but all things X-Files, including aliens, which I think belong to the sci-fi realm so I'll say:

Urban Fantasy is a contemporary genre-soup of an often-edgy story where the main ingredient is an element of the fantastic, be it fanged, furred, fey or other mythical type (kick-ass protags welcome but not truly necessary).
What do you think? Are we getting close?

NOTE: Illustrations are copyright of Timothy Lantz. The top illustration was used as the cover art for A Flash of Hex by Jes Battis, published by Juno Books. Please click on either image to go to Timothy Lantz's website.

Friday, July 11, 2008

Urban Fantasy Lacking In Social Commentary?

(cross posted from Urban Fantasy Fan)

I read a book review this evening (thanks Tez Miller!) that included the statement:
"... social commentary in urban fantasy (whether intended or not) often seems strangely absent."

She was remarking on the difference this novel* had because it DID include social commentary and is most definitely classified as Urban Fantasy.

But it got me thinking. Fantasy and Sci-Fi are often rife with it and the 'genre-apple' of urban fantasy really hasn't fallen SO far from that tree. Why IS social commentary "strangely absent" from this genre?

Before you get all ruffled and feel the need to defend Urban Fantasy from including anything other than compelling story telling of an 'other' kind, let me just say I'm not advocating that UF novels should have some sort of didactic purpose or deep political agenda. Not at all! I'm simply interested in the statement and wondering if this is in fact true, why this is the case.

Social commentary in literary circles can be defined as stating one's opinion with a view to causing societal and/or governmental change. In other words it's when authors write about the problems they see in society, hoping to wake up the general public to take notice and do something about it.

Now right there I can almost hear people say "well there's your answer! Who wants to be preached at?" But this is where fiction shines - because it can communicate messages without being preachy. Well known authors throughout history who engaged in social commentary in their writing include Charles Dickens, Oscar Wilde, Mark Twain and, of course, Jonathan Swift (thin Gulliver's Travels). In Sci-Fi we have Gene Rodenberry's vision of Star Trek and the currently popular New Battlestar Galactica TV shows. In fantasy circles it can even be argued that Tolkein's Lord of the Rings includes a level of social commentary.

So what about Urban Fantasy? Is it really so bereft social observation and a call to take note and take action?

Although I read a lot of urban fantasy I still have a lot to get through before I've read everything out there, or even a sampling of it all there so I am no expert by any means. It seems a given that social commentary 'a la The Colbert Report' won't have a place in fiction but the idea that Urban Fantasy is for the most part lacking in any form of it has made me rethink my recent reads, so I'll start there. I've just completed the Dresden Files series from first to most recent and personally I would argue that the White Council/Black Council issues could be regarded as social commentary, though granted they are more of a 'B' or 'C' plot than the main one. And Rachel Caine's Weather Warden series could be argued to hold a double whammy of social commentary about how we use the earth and its resources as well as the racial/class issues of the Djin.

Perhaps the reason Urban Fantasy doesn't appear to have much in the way of social commentary is because it's busy being really good at functioning as a metaphor for our personal lives, our relationships and where (and how) we fit into the larger societal whole, rather than focusing on the 'macro-issues' of things like governmental control and societal structure.

Thinking about this question of 'lack or not' has me looking at Urban Fantasy's potential for social commentary, whether or not the genre as a whole is currently a good representation of it or not. As far as getting my attention goes, Urban Fantasy is a good way to do it. Give me a pertinent issue to deal with (looking through the eyes of the heroine or hero) that's socially relevant and you can be sure I'll be considering it with regard to my real world too. And if you think about the popular protagonists of Urban Fantasy inspiring females to stand up for themselves and speak their mind (also known as 'empowerment' in social circles) that's already having quite an impact on everything from communication (beware the blog!) to consumerism (sexy, smart, sassy and savvy is definitely 'in' right now).

I'm only just starting to think about this. I haven't gotten off the fence yet and decided on one side or the other. Perhaps it's not important where I land but it IS interesting to think about and it's making me consider seriously about how I approach writing my UF worlds too. That can't be a bad thing!

Yes I'm playing devil's advocate here but since this is the place for smart and savvy people I'm putting it to you: what do you think?


* The novel is Blood Lines by Tanya Huff. Read Tez Miller's review here.

NOTE: Illustration copyright of Nelson Colon. Click on the pic to go to his website.

Friday, June 13, 2008

Genre Town: Digging Into the Foundations of Urban Fantasy

I'll be writing another post on the definition of Urban Fantasy sometime in the near future I'm sure but it's worth mentioning beforehand just how difficult it is to pin down. Not only that, despite this genre/sub-genre/subset/writing expression's slippery boundaries -

(that's right - people can't even agree on whether it's a 'real' genre or not! But for the sake of simplicity let's just say it is... besides, I don't feel like spending days with my nose in the dictionary trying to define definitions!)

- this doesn't-fit-any-known-pigeon-hole of a genre's ambiguity is, I believe, one of it's attractions.

There are theories on where Urban Fantasy originated but one thing is for certain: it WAS around before Buffy hit the small screen and became an instant cult classic. Perhaps not the little-girl-kicks-demon-ass-with-witty-repartee kind of Urban Fantasy but nevertheless it existed - as far back as the 1920's.

So, very quickly (because I should be asleep, not ruminating on various kinds of speculative fiction) here's the areas Urban Fantasy both overlaps with and owes its style to in a broad sense (though individual series may or may not include all of these):
  • Fantasy
  • Mythic Fiction
  • Dark Fantasy
  • Horror
  • Romance/Erotic Fiction
  • Suspense
  • Contemporary Fantasy
  • Fairy Tales
  • Urban Legends
  • Mysteries
  • Chick Lit
  • Comedy
  • Adventure Stories
  • Noir
  • Superheros (including comics)
While many believe Urban Fantasy has it's roots in the Horror genre there's no doubt it garners interest from a much wider fan base than horror fans. Urban Fantasy runs the gamut from darkly intense and gory to light comedic adventure-romps to erotic suspense and paranormal mysteries.

It's definitely a mixed bag - and that's one of it's best kept, yet most obvious secrets: Urban Fantasy's lack of specific definition and combination of varying genre elements has an incredibly wide appeal.

Urban Fantasy draws in readers from many different genres, who would NOT normally pick up fantasy, and has them reading - avidly. There's something for almost everyone - well, at least the genre has the scope for enough differences in style to attract many different kinds of readers - from the more serious to 'popcorn' readers.

The popcorn readers have it made with explosions, chases, sassy humor, the 'wow' factor of magic and the supernatural, gorgeously troubled girls who know how to wear high heeled boots, attractive bad boys/vampires/werewolves/whatever and underdog wins situations.

More serious readers get their appetites sated with a nod or more to myths, legends and history juxtaposed against a contemporary society full of modern issues and situations. The use of myth and legend often leads to the feeling of a modern-day fairy tale - and one that isn't necessarily guaranteed a happy ending.

It's this fairy tale aspect in a modern setting which makes it a perfect vehicle to examine issues, both personal and global, through metaphor and as a result - I believe - engenders a loyal following among fans who not only love the worlds but the people they're populated with.

To put it bluntly it's story candy that might actually be good for you!

What's not to love about that?

NOTE: All images ©Linda Bergkvist. Click on the pics to link back to her site FURIAE to see her amazing and extensive galleries or click on the banner below.

Saturday, June 7, 2008

Inkling: A Project By Any Other Name


"There’s a garden I visit nightly. It’s vast. I’m a lucid dreamer of the astral trailer park variety. These characters are part of the pantheon of my personal mythology, representations of myself, my friends, my obsessions, desires, fears… played out in urban fairy tale action adventures."
Alfonso Kellenberger


Inklings
, ideas... they tickle the back of your mind so you twitch uncomfortably in the midst of doing other things, making you want to screech to a halt and grab them before they dissipate in your exiting Muse's jet stream.

That impulse doesn't guarantee they'll be any good when you get a close look at them but the promise that they might be..? Every writer knows it's worth risking a pulled brain-muscle over, even if it's only to stop and check.

I had one of those rubber-braining ideas last night.

But first let me give you some context.

I've been trying to think of a way to combine subjects and genres I love into one big, ongoing writing-plus project and I think I'm getting close.

(What's a 'writing-plus' project? Hmm. I think I'll keep that under my hat for now. You'll just have to wait and see...)

This pot I've been throwing things into has the following predictable ingredients (well - it's predictable if you know me at all): a base soup of fairy tales (ye olde gritty ones), generous rashes of retold fairy tales (sometimes more of a stretch from their origins than you might think), rough chunks of urban fantasy (where the otherworld overlaps and influences the mortal one), a mix of myths and legends to taste and suspense for spice.

It's not a new idea to combine these facets to make a single type of story, or in my case string of stories, but pinning down exactly what I want the emphasis to be has been on the slippery side. I want enough room on the menu to serve a large enough variety to keep the reader's interest (and mine!) but still retain a specific 'genre-cuisine'.

Names help with that. Titles. They set up expectations as well as provide boundaries. For example, whatever this project ends up being called I want it to imply 'the fantastic' in a contemporary setting - a setting that's unlikely to cater to having the main characters argue about the efficiency of warp drives, for example.

So the question is:
How do you attract the attention of the edgier UF crowd as well as the Retold Fairy Tale enthusiasts?

It's not as simple as trying to figure out what would catch my attention because I'll look into anything if there's even a whiff of fairy tales about it. The books labeled as being written in the Urban Fantasy sub-genre just need a unique angle to make me read beyond the blurb.

I really think half the battle will be won if I can just find the right title... (the other half, of course, is making sure the stories have enough of everything to keep them all reading - including that original voice that they won't be able to get enough of... but that's a concern for another day.)

Last night at the ridiculous hour of 4am-and-change I found it! It had everything I was looking for including a creative use of the word 'Fae' to imply the fairy tale aspect.

One problem though - and it's kind of a big one.

The fairy tales I love and the re-tellings I admire contain a distinct LACK of Fae (faeries and fairies too!). The fact that they're called 'fairy tales' is rather incongruous and I totally understand why literary professors prefer to call these tales by the German word Marchen or simply Wonder Tales.

And that's my problem too. Though my stories qualify for the label 'urban fantasy' and the word 'Fae' (in the context I used it) implied 'fairy tales' my stories rarely have actual Fae in them. More often there's an incidental oh-by-the-way-this-amazing-thing-happened event that, while being a catalyst, isn't what the story is REALLY about at all.

Kinda like fairy tales.

So it's rather misleading to use 'Fae' or 'fairy' in the title when in fact the fairies are very few and far between. Werewolves? Yes. Magic practitioners? Certainly. Happily ever after with pixie-dust? Absolutely not. But I will be using fairy tales (some might say 'abusing' but that depends on your perspective), myths, legends and folktales to ground my stories.

Magic being used to give stories reality
- ironic, no?
Perhaps there's a clue right there...

And if any fairies appear there's a good chance they'll have teeth - sharp ones.

For now I think I'll just call it:
'Project Bite Me*'.


* An oft quoted Buffy-ism. I wonder if faeries like irony?

Wednesday, June 4, 2008

Genre Town: Urban Fantasy

I've been thinking about Urban Fantasy a lot for a while now. A long time reader, it's come into focus as a genre I should be paying attention to as a writer - specifically since last November when I joined a zombie writing hoard, known to the rest of the world as NaNoWriMo* participants, and realized the novel I was writing - titled 'Deadwood' - might just qualify for the genre - maybe.

It's a weird dilemma. When I think about 'Deadwood' as a suspense I write one way. If I'm thinking contemporary fantasy I focus on different things. If I think urban fantasy then I start flirting with a whole heap of ideas that, while tantalizing, may make me re-write some decent sized chunks of it - not that that's necessarily a bad thing. As long as the result is good I don't mind, though getting the bulk in the ball park on the first go would help my morale a lot!

Interestingly, I got the exact tone I wanted in the first two pages so when I get unfocused I go back, read those then start writing again. While that helps me write more story it hasn't helped me define exactly what genre it is, though I'm sure it would be perfectly be comfortable between other UF titles, despite the lack of vampires and werewolves roaming through the pages.

I'm still on the fence about which pigeon hole my story belongs in - I'm leaning toward contemporary fantasy suspense. How is that different from urban fantasy? *shrugs* It's not such a straight forward question. There's the perception of urban fantasy as opposed to what the publishing industry classify as urban fantasy and then, of course, there's the actual definition.

The label 'urban fantasy' implies a whole lot of things in which my story, while definitely following the path of this tradition, would not currently qualify as a main street attraction.

This got me thinking about what exactly urban fantasy was, is, where it's going and how popular it is. No matter how much people roll their eyes at sexy vampire and werewolf stories, the demand for them - and stories like them - seems to still be increasing. It's spilled over into the young adult and children's markets (whether or not it's Halloween), taken over the romance genre (as paranormal romance and/or erotica), invaded both the fantasy and sci-fi shelves (then been split up into 'urban fantasy' and 'contemporary urban fantasy' to boot) and has even made it's way onto the literary shelves - albeit by some initially clever disguises.

It's interesting to me that the more technologically savvy and dependent our society gets, the more people cry out for stories of magic in and among the mundane...

Can you tell I'm just getting warmed up on this topic?

Looks like I'll be making a base here for a bit so I can get my bearings, orient my stories and see just what it is that keeps bringing people back here. While I'm at it I might as well check in with the residents and see what they're up to these days. Better make sure my pen is loaded on my roamings though - you never know when you might run into some nasty local clichés!

In the meantime, zombie-like that I am, I should get some shut-eye. (It helps me avoid eating my own brains.)

Watch out creatures of the night, magic practitioners and all other residents of Urban Fantasy Town - the hunt is on!

I'll bag and tag you yet.

*National Novel Writing Month
NOTE: The artist featured is Linda Bergkvist. Click on the pictures to be taken to her pages and galleries.

Thursday, April 24, 2008

What Genre Would That Be Again?

In updating my 'About Me' page I realized I should put something about the sorts of stories I write. It's not that's it's hard to define so much as explain in a concise way that people understand on first hearing. It's not just that everything is so different (and that my first EBook is non-fiction!)

For example: My novel-in-progress 'Deadwood'.

During NaNoWriMo last year I hard a lot of trouble trying to find what genre to classify my story and ended up in the 'Other' category because it fit there best - which doesn't tell you anything of course! Apparently a few people were having similar issues with theirs and we got to chatting on the forums. It was suggested that perhaps I was leaning toward the Magic Realism category (not that there was a box to check for that) and it made a vague sort of sense.

My story is set in the present-day world in a fictional-but-could-be-real town and most everything that happens 'could' happen - except for the premise in which a dead body of a girl is brought back to life... I couldn't classify it as 'mystery' because it isn't all about the clues and the detectives. I couldn't classify it as romance, despite having a central relationship and I couldn't define it as 'literary fiction' because it's not primarily a character study. Adventure? Not really a journey-across-terrain kind of book or a combat/discovery sort of book either. I couldn't classify it as suspense, though it definitely has some of that, or thriller, or horror, though it's definitely not for the faint of heart. Fiction? Yes, but not the sort you might pull off the 'fiction' shelves at B&N. Yet I couldn't classify it as fantasy either because there just isn't much focus on on the fantastic or paranormal. Any 'happenings' may or may not be real. That part is left up to the reader (to some extent anyway). That said, there's a whole lot going on with an element of weird - all to the tune of a ticking clock...

Magic-realism almost fits. It might be happy next to 'Like Water For Chocolate, but only if it had a Dean Koontz novel on the other side. I don't think it would sit comfortably next to 'Love In the Time Of Cholera' at all!

So I've decided 'Deadwood' is 'fantastic-suspense' as it's more likely to end up on a fantasy shelf than any other.

But really, who cares right now? I should just write the story as it wants to be told. And that's all. Category-shmategory. Perhaps there'll be a new one by then anyway.